Family Feud

Well, this certainly ups the level of discourse: “Simple Sambo Wants to Move into the Big House.” Not. Be advised, the content might make your boss believe think that you’re surfing a white supremacist or neo-Nazi site, so you might want to wait until you get home to check it out. [The photo has been removed. You can see the update further down; however, you can also see the original photo at the bottom of this post.] That site isn’t white supremacist or neo-Nazi, however; it’s run by Steve Gilliard, a man of the Left who happens to be black. For those of you who are unwilling to go to the site, the post refers to the US Senate campaign of Lt. Governor Michael Steele (R-MD), who is also black. Mr. Gilliard has Photoshopped a Sambo-like blackface over a photo of Lt. Governor Steele, complete with huge rosy-red lips; one is reminded of the song “Old Man River” when looking at it, if one is of a certain age.

I have linked to Mr. Gilliard’s site a couple of times before, most famously when he accused Glenn Reynolds of racism for wearing this t-shirt (don’t ask me).

He went on to accuse Frank J. of being racist for the latter’s running gag regarding monkeys, because—according to Mr. Gilliard—the word ‘monkey’ is Frank’s code-speak for the n-word.

That gives you an idea of what we’re dealing with here.

This also gives you an idea of the state of much of the dialogue between black liberals and their conservative counterparts. Many (not all) black leftists don’t want to hear the theme of self-reliance; not unless it’s couched in anti-white rhetoric and practices (see the Nation of Islam), and even then it’s rarely a go. Often, when a conservative Republican of any color talks about the Republican method of self-reliance, some blacks on the Left don’t hear the words said; they hear whatever ideas that exist in their own mind about the Right. Hence we get posts like that of Mr. Gilliard’s, designed to inflame rather than to convince or reasonably oppose or encourage dialogue (he admits that he doesn’t want to talk). After all, who wants to get called offensive names or caricatured in the manner specified?

(Side note: white liberals take their cues on how to treat black conservatives from black liberals. Hence, white cartoonists like Jeff Danziger think it’s okay to liken Condoleezza Rice to Butterfly McQueen’s Prissie from Gone With the Wind.)

If this were the only type of dialogue between this ‘family,’ (sometimes literally family), I’d be very depressed. Fortunately it isn’t.

The Cobbfather (thanks, Avery) has long been at the forefront of intelligent dialogue between liberals and conservatives who happen to be black. (From the Left, Tony Pierce has also been very civil, at least to me.) Here is an excerpt from one of Cobb's most recent posts.

In my case, I found it rather sad that the cat engaging me was literally screaming for the answer to the question - What is the Republican plan for helping blacks in the ghetto? The quick answer to that question, any conservative will tell you in well rehearsed soundbites: We need you to help yourself out of the ghetto - it's a plantation of dependency from which you must escape. Of course when you get down into the details there's much more nuanced stuff to say, but there is one basic undeniable point on which most all on the Right will agree. America is not responsible for solving the ghetto dysfunction. In the infamous post-Katrina phrasing: "You're on your own".

This really sounds harsh to progressives, who are looking for ways to improve life through innovation and reform in government. It sounds downright evil to liberals whose expectations of government are to manage the problems of the relatively indigent. To conservatives, it sounds bracingly honest, forthright with a minimum of BS. It is the political equivalent of spinach, an ugly vegetable that actually is good for you and makes you stronger.

But here's where it get's particularly ugly - we inject race into it. And with race comes identity. As soon as you say 'black progressive' or 'black conservative' you've raised the complexity and volume of this simple ideological conflict. Here's why.

So, instead of letting the emotionalism provoked by Steve Gilliard’s post overwhelm you, go read Cobb’s post. Perhaps it will enlighten some who are willing to be enlightened.

(Thanks to Michelle Malkin, Robert George and Booker Rising)

UPDATE: Actions have consequences. Virginia gubernatorial Democrat candidate Tim Kaine has pulled his ads from Mr. Gilliard's site.

(Thanks to Expertise)

UPDATE: Story here. Now Mr. Gilliard says that Lt. Governor Kaine is racist for pulling the ad.

The blogger, Steve Gilliard, said the Kaine campaign had paid for a month of ads. He defended his attack on Steele and, after the Kaine campaign's action, changed the Web site again to feature an attack on Kaine as a "coward" for pulling the ads.

"I guess they have a problem with black people expressing themselves in print," Gilliard said. "At no point did they bother to ask me what I thought or why I did it."

What a charming fellow this Gilliard is.

It's pretty plain what he thinks.

UPDATE: David Anderson, noted man of the Left, also black, also hasn't let our ideological differences get in the way of his being a gentleman. I've even been a guest poster at his place.

UPDATE: Mr. Gilliard has taken down the altered photo, apparently at the behest of the Washington Post who owned the original.

Comments

[Jack]

I keep hoping for the day to come where skin color is never mentioned in any political discussion.

I grew up in the South (yes, Capitalized, because there was a distinction at the time that has become blurred somewhat in the decades since) as a white boy.

I saw and heard many things that were endorsed by "right-thinking folks" that now make me suspicious any time that I read or hear the phrase "right-thinking" (I recently wrote a post about it that I won't link-whore here).

This is such an intractable issue.

Even as a white male in the United States, I discovered first-hand what it was like to be subject to discrimination based upon race when I worked for a Japanese company beneath a succession of managers from various Asian nations (Korea, Japan, and Taiwan). I wasn't of the correct race in their eyes, therefore I was discriminated against in favor of those who were. So, even though I have not had to directly experience the enveloping cultural aspects of it (except for my extended visits to Japan), I do have a better understanding than many white males raised in the South of 35 years ago of all the emotions evoked by racism and unfair treatment.

Sigh.

I don't have the words to express what needs to be said.

Perhaps no one does, unless we can find another Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., but I fear that type of leadership has been lost to our generation, regardless of skin color or heritage.

I guess that is the best ending of this muddled stream of consciousness comment.

My apologies.

[Froggy]

Unbelievable. That is the most racist image I think I have ever seen. I linked him too at FR, because hey, we gotta get the word out on these shitheads.

[DarkStar]

Affirmative action: for it.
Support Black business: for it.
Black business set asides: for it.
Spoken out against Republican Southern Strategy: did it.
Appears on Black talk radio in the Baltimore area: check.

Yep. "Sambo".

[DarkStar]

OH, in case it's not clear, those are things Michael Steele did and/or supports.

[baldilocks]

So basically what you're saying, Darkstar, is that Steele is an independent thinker and definitely doesn't deserve the treatment he got from SG, right?

[T-Steel]

There will come a time when we black folks are going to have to just say:

DO THE RIGHT THING!

And the "right" thing is the realize we won the civil rights movement. MLK, Malcolm X, and company did it. They won. Now we are in a new phase. And that phase entails a tad bit of unity to do postive things in the black community economically! Notice I didn't say socially. To heck with social stuff. People don't have to like you in order to do business with you. It's all about the product folks.

I don't live far from Dearborn, Michigan which is home to the largest Arab-American population in the USA. They have stores, restaurants, dentists, etc. And they are still profitable even with the increased scrutiny they get these days. White, black, yellow, brown, orange, pink, silver, and red all continue to buy from them. Why? Because they have something that those folks like. Legislation doesn't change society like a product does. Look at the iPod. The iPod has changed the world. It has changed the music market. It has changed social customs. It's ingrained in our language.

At our basic levels of civilization, we humans trade. And trade has pulled humans out of many a difficult situation. What say you?

[teal marie]

Sambo prevails in the story and I always thought tiger butter sounded especially delicious. Yummmmmmm

[-keith in mtn. view]

Thanks for the link to Cobb. As a result of reading the comments section I had to Google, "fumbling with Piscarcikian aplomb."

[Cobb]

I've got a stronger stomach than the average bear, so I've generally been dismissive of the self-pity I've heard from black neocons about all the 'courage' they've had to possess in the midst of black liberals. But I guarantee you that some of the things you are bound to hear as a black conservative will bring tears to your eyes.

It's just like that famous quote from the liberal New Yorker, "I don't even *know* anyone who voted for George W. Bush". Black liberals have been stewing in their own juices for so long that they have no idea what black conservatives are like.

Anyway, we're trying to change that, and the new Conservative Brotherhood website is all about facilitating a lot of discussions that need to happen.

[-keith in mtn. view]

I grew up 100-miles south of Calcutta and the other kids threw rocks, hard mangoes, and other stuff at my brother and me calling us "monkey". On several occasions the local people surrounded our vehicle to prevent us from getting out and enjoying and joining-in a national celebration - ironically one of those was "Children's Day." Discrimination isn't exclusive in practice or subject to any particular color or creed.

[David Anderson]

Hey! I have been nice to you too sister! Hehe... And I agree with you, I posted my own response to Steve's post.

[baldilocks]

David,

You have, indeed been a sweetheart to me. Please forgive my terrible oversight! ::::mortified and corrected::::

[Froggy]

Jackass Steve took down the minstrel photoshop picture apparently at the behest of the Washington Post. I would say something about knuckling under to the MSM, but I'm just glad that trash is gone.

[baldilocks]

Thanks for the heads-up, Froggy.